Back
Subject: Corporate News
Reading time: 1 Min
09.03.2023

Vis Moot Court — Trial Run at Prager Dreifuss

Finally, another student showdown on the 6th floor at Prager Dreifuss! On 8 March 2023, the claimant, drone manufacturer Drone Eye plc, represented by Filippo Börner (procedural issues) and Manuel Constam (substantive issues) from the University of St. Gallen, attended the oral hearing in the arbitral proceedings against respondent, state-owned company Equatoriana Geoscience Ltd, represented by Julia Bischof (procedural issues) and Alex Brückler (substantive issues) from the University of Bern.

In substance, claimant wants to be awarded damages under the purchase and supply agreement for 6 reconnaissance aircraft which it concluded with respondent. However, allegations of corruption, fraud and misrepresentation as well as dubious machinations play an important role alongside questions of jurisdiction and applicable law. The St. Gallen team displayed good file knowledge and communicated well. The students from Bern counterpunched with solid technical details on the purchase objects and valiantly countered the barrage of questions by the tribunal.

Well done! But you can always learn something new. The party representatives were able to take home some valuable input from the arbitrators, who could not come to a unanimous finding and decided to split the prize money equally among both contesting teams.

Julia Bischof from the University of Bern opens the debate. Julia Bischof from the University of Bern opens the debate.

Julia Bischof from the University of Bern opens the debate.

“Let me tell you, what this is all about…” “Let me tell you, what this is all about…”

“Let me tell you, what this is all about…”

Filippo Börner (University of St. Gallen) refutes the arguments... Filippo Börner (University of St. Gallen) refutes the arguments...

Filippo Börner (University of St. Gallen) refutes the arguments...

...and Manuel Constam underscores the position with case law references. ...and Manuel Constam underscores the position with case law references.

...and Manuel Constam underscores the position with case law references.

Alex Brückler concludes the round of pleadings. Alex Brückler concludes the round of pleadings.

Alex Brückler concludes the round of pleadings.

Some of the arguments gave rise to some mirth among the arbitrators... Some of the arguments gave rise to some mirth among the arbitrators...

Some of the arguments gave rise to some mirth among the arbitrators...

...although their main task is to listen well... ...although their main task is to listen well...

...although their main task is to listen well...

...and ask testing and  uncomfortable questions. ...and ask testing and uncomfortable questions.

...and ask testing and uncomfortable questions.

Finally, everyone relaxes... Finally, everyone relaxes...

Finally, everyone relaxes...

...and discusses over a glass of wine ...and discusses over a glass of wine

...and discusses over a glass of wine